Back to Recipes

Pumpkin Cream Cheese Cookie Sandwiches

When the air turns cool in Fall, all I want to do is bake and drink tea…. because I have SOOOOO much free time (this is sarcasm, if you could not tell).

One of the reasons I simply love our cookie mixes is because they are so easy. Spending the day baking from scratch is wonderful but I am not one who has that kind of time. It is especially hard to find some yummy gluten free treats that my NON-Gluten-Free-Friends will want to eat. So here we have soft warm cinnamon oatmeal cookies with a smooth and super easy pumpkin cream cheese filling. What a treat!

 

Pumpkin Cream Cheese Cookie Sandwiches

Servings 10 or More
Prep Time 20
Cook Time 20
Difficulty Level Easy
Course
Dessert, Snack
Diet Type
Gluten Free, Vegetarian
  • One box of Cucina Aurora Cinnamon Oatmeal Cookie Mix (make cookies to package instructions)
  • 8 oz cream cheese, softened
  • 4 oz (1/2 cup) pumpkin puree
  • 1 Tablespoon cinnamon
  • 1 Tablespoon Pumpkin Pie Spice
  • 1/4 cup brown sugar
  1. Bake cookies to package instructions (you will only need 1 box of cookie mix, coconut oil OR butter, and unsweetened apple sauce). Cool cookies completely.
  2. In a medium bowl, combine cream cheese, pumpkin, cinnamon, pumpkin pie spice, and brown sugar.
  3. Beat with an electric mixer on medium about 1 minute until well combined and smooth.
  4. Spread cream cheese mixture on one flat side of cookie and make a sandwich. Repeat with remaining cookies. Refrigerate in an air tight container for up to a week. Freeze for up to a month. ENJOY!

What Our Customers Say

The best infused olive oils anywhere! I keep my kitchen stocked and have given them as housewarming and even engagement gifts. Delicious, top quality product and exceptional customer service. I’m a long time customer and they have earned their 5 stars!

Mariana O.
Google 5 Star Review

Delicious!!! Cucina Aurora oils are the best tasting oils out there!  Every time, I use them with guests, they always ask about flavors. I continued to try different brands of flavored oils over the past 9 years, but none of them compare to Cucina Aurora.  They are fantastic on vegetables, breads, and salads.  You can really taste a smooth flavor of each flavor.  I highly recommend you try any of the oils!  You won’t be disappointed

Jordan M.
Google 5 Star Review

The risotto packages are great! Easy to make, with few additional ingredients. Makes two hearty portions. Fast delivery. I’ve ordered from this place before and I’ll order again.

Pat B
Facebook Review

Just had sweet potato sage risotto purchased recently. Absolutely wonderful, and easy!!!! A gem!

Andrea J.

Love every single variety of infused olive oil available and the new coffee is decadent

Lynn Marie K.
Facebook Review

The oils are AMAZING!!! We haven’t tried a flavor yet that we aren’t absolutely crazy about!

Tim B.
Google 5 Star Review

I have purchased many products from Cucina Aurora Kitchen Witchery over the years. Dip mix, risotto, cookbooks and of course oils! What keeps me coming back is the fact that everything is just plain good. I love to cook and the oils in particular make it simple to add a delicious burst of flavor. I tell everyone about these products and will keep spreading the word!

Catherine P.
Google 5 Star Review

Outstanding woman-owned business with exceptional quality. Highly recommend every single thing she manufactures and sells!!!

Tina M.
5 Star Google Review

I have a huge food allergy and have to avoid many things. The olive oil I buy from Cucina Aurora is delicious! I know exactly what is in it, I cook with it, and use it on salads. What a twist to add to a salad and it is amazing on shrimp! Thank you Dawn for adding yummy flavor to my very limited menu!

Eileen K.
Facebook Review

I just received the Winter Brew coffee and Rosemary olive oil and love them so much! I think the winter brew just might be my new favorite coffee. I can’t wait to try the other seasons!

Kalie B.
Facebook Revi

I genuinely love every product this company makes. I’ve been blessed with meeting members of the team in person and got nothing but good vibes and have been lucky to find local establishments in which to purchase their oils and coffee. You can’t go wrong with buying food items from a kitchen witch!

Candence H.
Google 5 Star Review

I was fortunate to stop at the Kitchen Witchery booth at Mohegan Sun New England Christmas Festival. I purchased the Magical Marinara and that is what it is “magical” I cooked my meatballs in the sauce. The flavor was delicious with the garlic infused olive oil and a slight kick of red pepper we thoroughly enjoyed it! I will definitely be purchasing it again and will be trying the infused olive oils!

Pamala M.
Google 5 Star Review